In Python, if I return inside a "with" block, will the file still close?

Question

Consider the following:

with open(path, mode) as f:
    return [line for line in f if condition]

Will the file be closed properly, or does using return somehow bypass the context manager?

Asked By: Lightbreeze

||

Source

Answer 1

Yes, it acts like the finally block after a try block, i.e. it always executes (unless the python process terminates in an unusual way of course).

It is also mentioned in one of the examples of PEP-343 which is the specification for the with statement:

with locked(myLock):
    # Code here executes with myLock held.  The lock is
    # guaranteed to be released when the block is left (even
    # if via return or by an uncaught exception).

Something worth mentioning is however, that you cannot easily catch exceptions thrown by the open() call without putting the whole with block inside a try..except block which is usually not what one wants.

Answered By: ThiefMaster

Answer 2

Yes.

def example(path, mode):
    with open(path, mode) as f:
        return [line for line in f if condition]

..is pretty much equivalent to:

def example(path, mode):
    f = open(path, mode)

    try:
        return [line for line in f if condition]
    finally:
        f.close()

More accurately, the __exit__ method in a context manager is always called when exiting the block (regardless of exceptions, returns etc). The file object’s __exit__ method just calls f.close() (e.g here in CPython)

Answered By: dbr

Answer 3

Yes. More generally, the __exit__ method of a With Statement Context Manager will indeed be called in the event of a return from inside the context. This can be tested with the following:

class MyResource:
    def __enter__(self):
        print('Entering context.')
        return self

    def __exit__(self, *exc):
        print('EXITING context.')

def fun():
    with MyResource():
        print('Returning inside with-statement.')
        return
    print('Returning outside with-statement.')

fun()

The output is:

Entering context.
Returning inside with-statement.
EXITING context.

The output above confirms that __exit__ was called despite the early return. As such, the context manager is not bypassed.

Answered By: Asclepius

Answer 4

Yes, but there may be some side effect in other cases, because it may should do something (like flushing buffer) in __exit__ block

import gzip
import io

def test(data):
    out = io.BytesIO()
    with gzip.GzipFile(fileobj=out, mode="wb") as f:
        f.write(data)
        return out.getvalue()

def test1(data):
    out = io.BytesIO()
    with gzip.GzipFile(fileobj=out, mode="wb") as f:
        f.write(data)
    return out.getvalue()

print(test(b"test"), test1(b"test"))

# b'x1fx8bx08x00x95x1bxb3[x02xff' b'x1fx8bx08x00x95x1bxb3[x02xff+I-.x01x00x0c~x7fxd8x04x00x00x00'

Answered By: virusdefender

In Python, if I return inside a "with" block, will the file still close?

Question:

Answers: