Python ConfigParser: Checking for option existence
Question:
I’m using Python’s ConfigParser to create a configuration file. I want to check if a section has a particular option defined and, if it does, get the value. If the option isn’t defined, I just want to continue without any special behavior. There seem to be two ways of doing this.
if config.has_option('Options', 'myoption'):
OPTION = config.get('Options', 'myoption')
Or:
try:
OPTION = config.get('Options', 'myoption')
except ConfigParser.NoOptionError:
pass
Is one method preferred over the other? The if involves less lines, but I’ve occasionally read that try/except is considered more pythonic in many cases.
Answers:
The choice between try/except and if-condition is a fuzzy line.
- If you expect the exception to be quite rare, use try/except as it more closely models thinking
- Conversely, “expected” exceptions like a configuration item missing, are part of the normal flow of control and the code should reflect that.
There is no clearly superior choice, but it sounds like you’ve got a case of (2) so I’d opt for if/then. This completely ignores aspects of Easier to ask Forgiveness Than Permission and the relative efficiencies of the structures.
I’m using Python’s ConfigParser to create a configuration file. I want to check if a section has a particular option defined and, if it does, get the value. If the option isn’t defined, I just want to continue without any special behavior. There seem to be two ways of doing this.
if config.has_option('Options', 'myoption'):
OPTION = config.get('Options', 'myoption')
Or:
try:
OPTION = config.get('Options', 'myoption')
except ConfigParser.NoOptionError:
pass
Is one method preferred over the other? The if involves less lines, but I’ve occasionally read that try/except is considered more pythonic in many cases.
The choice between try/except and if-condition is a fuzzy line.
- If you expect the exception to be quite rare, use try/except as it more closely models thinking
- Conversely, “expected” exceptions like a configuration item missing, are part of the normal flow of control and the code should reflect that.
There is no clearly superior choice, but it sounds like you’ve got a case of (2) so I’d opt for if/then. This completely ignores aspects of Easier to ask Forgiveness Than Permission and the relative efficiencies of the structures.