Why is a trailing comma a SyntaxError in an argument list that uses *args syntax?

Question

Why can’t you use a trailing comma with *args in Python? In other words, this works

>>> f(1, 2, b=4,)

But this does not

>>> f(*(1, 2), b=4,)
  File "<stdin>", line 1
    f(*(1, 2), b=4,)
                   ^
SyntaxError: invalid syntax

This is the case with both Python 2 and Python 3.

Asked By: asmeurer

||

Source

Answer 1

Let’s look at the language specification:

call                 ::=  primary "(" [argument_list [","]
                          | expression genexpr_for] ")"
argument_list        ::=  positional_arguments ["," keyword_arguments]
                            ["," "*" expression] ["," keyword_arguments]
                            ["," "**" expression]
                          | keyword_arguments ["," "*" expression]
                            ["," "**" expression]
                          | "*" expression ["," "*" expression] ["," "**" expression]
                          | "**" expression
positional_arguments ::=  expression ("," expression)*
keyword_arguments    ::=  keyword_item ("," keyword_item)*
keyword_item         ::=  identifier "=" expression

Let’s sift down to the parts we care about:

call                 ::=  primary "(" [argument_list [","]] ")"
argument_list        ::=  positional_arguments ["," keyword_arguments]
                            ["," "*" expression] ["," keyword_arguments]
                            ["," "**" expression]
positional_arguments ::=  expression ("," expression)*
keyword_arguments    ::=  keyword_item ("," keyword_item)*
keyword_item         ::=  identifier "=" expression

So, it looks like after any arguments to a function call, we’re allowed an extra ,. So this looks like a bug in the cpython implementation.

Something like: f(1, *(2,3,4), ) should work according to this grammar, but doesn’t in CPython.

In an earlier answer, Eric linked to the CPython grammar specification, which includes the CPython implementation of the above grammar. Here it is below:

arglist: (argument ',')* ( argument [',']
                         | '*' test (',' argument)* [',' '**' test] 
                         | '**' test
                         )

Note, that this grammar is not the same as the one proposed by the language specification. I’d consider this an implementation bug.

Note that there are additional issues with the CPython implementation. This should also be supported: f(*(1,2,3), *(4,5,6))

Oddly though, the specification does not allow f(*(1,2,3), *(4,5,6), *(7,8,9))

As I look at this more, I think this part of the specification needs some fixing. This is allowed: f(x=1, *(2,3)), but this isn’t: f(x=1, 2, 3).

And to perhaps be helpful to the original question, in CPython, you can have a trailing comma if you don’t use the *args or the **kwargs feature. I agree that this is lame.

Answered By: Bill Lynch

Answer 2

After some discussion regarding this bug in issue 9232, Guido van Rossum commented:

I’m +1 on adding this. I don’t believe it requires a PEP. A trailing comma in definitions is already supported in some places, so I don’t buy the argument that it catches errors. During the moratorium we were perhaps too strict.

Subsequently, a patch by Mark Dickinson was committed. So this is now fixed in Python 3.6.0 alpha 1.

Answered By: BioGeek

Why is a trailing comma a SyntaxError in an argument list that uses *args syntax?

Question:

Answers: