In Python, what does dict.pop(a,b) mean?

Question

class a(object):
    data={'a':'aaa','b':'bbb','c':'ccc'}
    def pop(self, key, *args):
            return self.data.pop(key, *args)#what is this mean.

b=a()
print b.pop('a',{'b':'bbb'})
print b.data

self.data.pop(key, *args) ←—— why is there a second argument?

Asked By: zjm1126

||

Source

Answer 1

def func(*args): 
    pass

When you define a function this way, *args will be array of arguments passed to the function. This allows your function to work without knowing ahead of time how many arguments are going to be passed to it.

You do this with keyword arguments too, using **kwargs:

def func2(**kwargs): 
    pass

See: Arbitrary argument lists

In your case, you’ve defined a class which is acting like a dictionary. The dict.pop method is defined as pop(key[, default]).

Your method doesn’t use the default parameter. But, by defining your method with *args and passing *args to dict.pop(), you are allowing the caller to use the default parameter.

In other words, you should be able to use your class’s pop method like dict.pop:

my_a = a()
value1 = my_a.pop('key1')       # throw an exception if key1 isn't in the dict
value2 = my_a.pop('key2', None) # return None if key2 isn't in the dict

Answered By: Seth

Answer 2

The pop method of dicts (like self.data, i.e. {'a':'aaa','b':'bbb','c':'ccc'}, here) takes two arguments — see the docs

The second argument, default, is what pop returns if the first argument, key, is absent.
(If you call pop with just one argument, key, it raises an exception if that key’s absent).

In your example, print b.pop('a',{'b':'bbb'}), this is irrelevant because 'a' is a key in b.data. But if you repeat that line…:

b=a()
print b.pop('a',{'b':'bbb'})
print b.pop('a',{'b':'bbb'})
print b.data

you’ll see it makes a difference: the first pop removes the 'a' key, so in the second pop the default argument is actually returned (since 'a' is now absent from b.data).

Answered By: Alex Martelli

Answer 3

So many questions here. I see at least two, maybe three:

What does pop(a,b) do?/Why are there a second argument?
What is *args being used for?

The first question is trivially answered in the Python Standard Library reference:

pop(key[, default])

If key is in the dictionary, remove it and return its value, else return default.
If default is not given and key is not in the dictionary, a KeyError is raised.

The second question is covered in the Python Language Reference:

If the form “*identifier” is present,
it is initialized to a tuple receiving
any excess positional parameters,
defaulting to the empty tuple. If the
form “**identifier” is present, it is
initialized to a new dictionary
receiving any excess keyword
arguments, defaulting to a new empty
dictionary.

In other words, the pop function takes at least two arguments. The first two get assigned the names self and key; and the rest are stuffed into a tuple called args.

What’s happening on the next line when *args is passed along in the call to self.data.pop is the inverse of this – the tuple *args is expanded to of positional parameters which get passed along. This is explained in the Python Language Reference:

If the syntax *expression appears in
the function call, expression must
evaluate to a sequence. Elements from
this sequence are treated as if they
were additional positional arguments

In short, a.pop() wants to be flexible and accept any number of positional parameters, so that it can pass this unknown number of positional parameters on to self.data.pop().

This gives you flexibility; data happens to be a dict right now, and so self.data.pop() takes either one or two parameters; but if you changed data to be a type which took 19 parameters for a call to self.data.pop() you wouldn’t have to change class a at all. You’d still have to change any code that called a.pop() to pass the required 19 parameters though.

Answered By: James Polley

Answer 4

>>> def func(a, *args, **kwargs):
...   print 'a %s, args %s, kwargs %s' % (a, args, kwargs)
... 
>>> func('one', 'two', 'three', four='four', five='five')
a one, args ('two', 'three'), kwargs {'four': 'four', 'five': 'five'}

>>> def anotherfunct(beta, *args):
...   print 'beta %s, args %s' % (beta, args)
... 
>>> def func(a, *args, **kwargs):
...   anotherfunct(a, *args)
... 
>>> func('one', 'two', 'three', four='four', five='five')
beta one, args ('two', 'three')
>>>

Answered By: James Polley

In Python, what does dict.pop(a,b) mean?

Question:

Answers: