Changing values of a list of namedtuples

Question

I have a list of namedtuples named Books and am trying to increase the price field by 20% which does change the value of Books. I tried to do:

from collections import namedtuple
Book = namedtuple('Book', 'author title genre year price instock')
BSI = [
       Book('Suzane Collins','The Hunger Games', 'Fiction', 2008, 6.96, 20),
       Book('J.K. Rowling', "Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone", 'Fantasy', 1997, 4.78, 12)]
for item in BSI:
    item = item.price*1.10
print(item.price)

But I keep getting :

 Traceback (most recent call last):
 print(item.price)
 AttributeError: 'float' object has no attribute 'price'

I understand that I cannot set the fields in a namedtuple. How do I go about updating price?

I tried to make it into a function:

def restaurant_change_price(rest, newprice):
    rest.price = rest._replace(price = rest.price + newprice)
    return rest.price

print(restaurant_change_price(Restaurant("Taillevent", "French", "343-3434", "Escargots", 24.50), 25))

but I get an error with replace saying:

 rest.price = rest._replace(price = rest.price + newprice)
 AttributeError: can't set attribute

Can someone let me know why this is happening?

Asked By: Leon Surrao

||

Source

Answer 1

Named tuples are immutable, so you cannot manipulate them.

Right way of doing it:

If you want something mutable, you can use recordtype.

from recordtype import recordtype

Book = recordtype('Book', 'author title genre year price instock')
books = [
   Book('Suzane Collins','The Hunger Games', 'Fiction', 2008, 6.96, 20),
   Book('J.K. Rowling', "Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone", 'Fantasy', 1997, 4.78, 12)]

for book in books:
    book.price *= 1.1
    print(book.price)

PS: You may need to pip install recordtype if you don’t have it installed.

Bad way of doing it:

You may also keep using namedtuple with using the _replace() method.

from collections import namedtuple

Book = namedtuple('Book', 'author title genre year price instock')
books = [
   Book('Suzane Collins','The Hunger Games', 'Fiction', 2008, 6.96, 20),
   Book('J.K. Rowling', "Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone", 'Fantasy', 1997, 4.78, 12)]

for i in range(len(books)):
    books[i] = books[i]._replace(price = books[i].price*1.1)
    print(books[i].price)

Answered By: Sait

Answer 2

This looks like a task for Python’s data analysis library, pandas. It’s really, really easy to do this sort of thing:

In [6]: import pandas as pd
In [7]: df = pd.DataFrame(BSI, columns=Book._fields)
In [8]: df
Out[8]: 
           author                                  title    genre  year  
0  Suzane Collins                       The Hunger Games  Fiction  2008   
1    J.K. Rowling  Harry Potter and the Sorcerers Stone  Fantasy  1997   

   price  instock  
0   6.96       20  
1   4.78       12  

In [9]: df['price'] *= 100
In [10]: df
Out[10]: 
           author                                  title    genre  year  
0  Suzane Collins                       The Hunger Games  Fiction  2008   
1    J.K. Rowling  Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone  Fantasy  1997   

   price  instock  
0    696       20  
1    478       12

Now isn’t that just much, much better than labouring with namedtuples?

Answered By: LondonRob

Answer 3

In Python >= 3.7 you can use dataclass decorator with the new variable annotations feature to produce mutable record types:

from dataclasses import dataclass


@dataclass
class Book:
    author: str
    title: str
    genre: str
    year: int
    price: float
    instock: int


BSI = [
    Book("Suzane Collins", "The Hunger Games", "Fiction", 2008, 6.96, 20),
    Book(
        "J.K. Rowling",
        "Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone",
        "Fantasy",
        1997,
        4.78,
        12,
    ),
]

for item in BSI:
    item.price *= 1.10
    print(f"New price for '{item.title}' book is {item.price:,.2f}")

Output:

New price for 'The Hunger Games' book is 7.66
New price for 'Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone' book is 5.26

Answered By: Vlad Bezden

Changing values of a list of namedtuples

Question:

Answers:

Right way of doing it:

Bad way of doing it: