Why can't dataclasses have mutable defaults in their class attributes declaration?

Question

This seems like something that is likely to have been asked before, but an hour or so of searching has yielded no results. Passing default list argument to dataclasses looked promising, but it’s not quite what I’m looking for.

Here’s the problem: when one tries to assign a mutable value to a class attribute, there’s an error:

@dataclass
class Foo:
    bar: list = []

# ValueError: mutable default <class 'list'> for field a is not allowed: use default_factory

I gathered from the error message that I’m supposed to use the following instead:

@dataclass
class Foo:
    bar: list = field(default_factory=list)

But why are mutable defaults not allowed? Is it to enforce avoidance of the mutable default argument problem?

Asked By: Graham

||

Source

Answer 1

It looks like my question was quite clearly answered in the docs (which derived from PEP 557, as shmee mentioned):

Python stores default member variable values in class attributes. Consider this example, not using dataclasses:
class C:
    x = []
    def add(self, element):
        self.x.append(element)

o1 = C()
o2 = C()
o1.add(1)
o2.add(2)
assert o1.x == [1, 2]
assert o1.x is o2.x
Note that the two instances of class C share the same class variable x, as expected.

Using dataclasses, if this code was valid:
@dataclass
class D:
    x: List = []
    def add(self, element):
        self.x += element
it would generate code similar to:
class D:
    x = []
    def __init__(self, x=x):
        self.x = x
    def add(self, element):
        self.x += element
This has the same issue as the original example using class C. That is, two instances of class D that do not specify a value for x when creating a class instance will share the same copy of x. Because dataclasses just use normal Python class creation they also share this behavior. There is no general way for Data Classes to detect this condition. Instead, dataclasses will raise a ValueError if it detects a default parameter of type list, dict, or set. This is a partial solution, but it does protect against many common errors.

Answered By: Graham

Answer 2

The above answer is not correct. A mutable default value, such as an empty list can be defined in data class by using default_factory.

    @dataclass
    class D:
        x: list = field(default_factory=list)

Using default factory functions is a way to create new instances of >mutable types as default values for fields:
   @dataclass
   class D:
       x: list = field(default_factory=list)

   assert D().x is not D().x

The link is here

Answered By: Shizzy

Answer 3

import field like dataclass.

from dataclasses import dataclass, field

and use this for lists:

@dataclass
class Foo:
    bar: list = field(default_factory=list)

Answered By: Sadegh Pouriyan

Answer 4

Just use a callable in your default_factory:

from dataclasses import dataclass, field

@dataclass
class SomeClass:
    """
    """

    some_list: list = field(default_factory=lambda: ["your_values"])

If you want all instances to mutate the same list:

from dataclasses import dataclass, field

SHARED_LIST = ["your_values"]
    
@dataclass
class SomeClass:
    """
    """
    
    some_list: list = field(default_factory=lambda: SHARED_LIST)

Answered By: Metalstorm

Why can't dataclasses have mutable defaults in their class attributes declaration?

Question:

Answers: