Comparison of IntelliJ Python plugin or PyCharm
Question:
So I have IntelliJ and love it, and have been using the Python plugin for a while. But I noticed that they have PyCharm coming out in beta now. I haven’t been using PyCharm since I just use IntelliJ for everything, but is there a compelling reason to buy PyCharm?
Answers:
PyCharm supports django and Google App Engine. The django support is really nice if you use django.
Right now PyCharm is quite a bit farther ahead in terms of functionality compared to the Python plugin for IntelliJ IDEA 9. Once we start the EAP for IntelliJ IDEA 10, we’ll also release a new version of the Python plugin containing all the latest features of PyCharm, but we don’t currently plan to backport the new features to the IDEA 9 version of the plugin. So, if you’re OK with using EAP builds of IntelliJ IDEA, you shouldn’t need to buy a separate license for PyCharm.
Right now Pycharm does a much better job of detecting and automatically configuring itself to run existing Google App Engine apps. Using IntelliJ and the plugin requires quite a few steps to get an existing project to run.
In PyCharm all you really have to do is configure a run configuration
Script: /path/to/dev_appserver.py
Script Parameters: /path/to/your/app
Make sure you configure Python 2.5.x as your interpreter.
For comparison: In IntelliJ you need to first add a Python module to your project, then add Google App Engine to that perspective. None of that is at all obvious as you are trying to do it as IntelliJ will want to create new module directories rather than use your existing code.
Since this question (and its accepted answer) are older and new
versions of both IDEA and PyCharm are available, I figured it would be
appropriate to add a new answer without modifying the existing
“correct” one…
My company has licenses for both PyCharm 1.5 and IntelliJ IDEA 10.5 and I have used both for regular Python development and Django web app development. From my experience, I have not found any features of PyCharm which were not available to me using the Python plugin for IntelliJ.
This makes sense if you consider the fact thet the Python IntelliJ plugin is actually maintained by the PyCharm developers at JetBrains. The only catch to this is that there could be brand new features released to a new version of PyCharm which would not be immediately available to the plugin users but it probably wouldn’t take them long to port them over.
If you are considering buying a license for IntelliJ, I would recommend to not also buy a PyCharm license as it seems like a waste of money. However, if you only do Python related development, I would recommend to only buy the PyCharm IDE instead because its licenses are cheaper than IDEA’s.
UPDATE (2013-01-23)
I have been recently using IntelliJ IDEA v12 with the latest (2.10.0) python plugin instead of PyCharm. As an experienced IDEA user, this is my preferred situation. For someone with no (or less) IDEA experience, JetBrains actually recommends starting with PyCharm because it’s UI is simpler and more focused on productivity within Python projects.
As for feature difference, JetBrains claims that the Python plugin is built from exactly the same source as PyCharm so the features should be identical. The only differences should be with the user experience, where IDEA’s plugin is slightly harder to use because that IDE isn’t aimed at Python development in the first place.
JetBrains has a FAQ that has more info about differences between the IDEA plugin and PyCharm.
IntelliJ’s comarison of IntelliJ IDEA and PyCharm.
http://confluence.jetbrains.net/display/PYH/PyCharm+vs.+IntelliJ+IDEA+Python+plugin+FAQ
From their blog:
Nov., 22nd 2012 – Just a quick heads up: we’ve just released a version
of the Python plugin for the latest Early Access Preview build of
IntelliJ IDEA 12 (build 123.4). The plugin includes the entire
functionality of the current PyCharm 2.7 EAP, including several
features which were previously only available in PyCharm (creating
virtualenvs, using remote interpreters, creating UML diagrams for
Python code etc.).
Source: http://blog.jetbrains.com/pycharm/2012/11/python-plugin-for-intellij-idea-12-is-now-available/
So I have IntelliJ and love it, and have been using the Python plugin for a while. But I noticed that they have PyCharm coming out in beta now. I haven’t been using PyCharm since I just use IntelliJ for everything, but is there a compelling reason to buy PyCharm?
PyCharm supports django and Google App Engine. The django support is really nice if you use django.
Right now PyCharm is quite a bit farther ahead in terms of functionality compared to the Python plugin for IntelliJ IDEA 9. Once we start the EAP for IntelliJ IDEA 10, we’ll also release a new version of the Python plugin containing all the latest features of PyCharm, but we don’t currently plan to backport the new features to the IDEA 9 version of the plugin. So, if you’re OK with using EAP builds of IntelliJ IDEA, you shouldn’t need to buy a separate license for PyCharm.
Right now Pycharm does a much better job of detecting and automatically configuring itself to run existing Google App Engine apps. Using IntelliJ and the plugin requires quite a few steps to get an existing project to run.
In PyCharm all you really have to do is configure a run configuration
Script: /path/to/dev_appserver.py
Script Parameters: /path/to/your/app
Make sure you configure Python 2.5.x as your interpreter.
For comparison: In IntelliJ you need to first add a Python module to your project, then add Google App Engine to that perspective. None of that is at all obvious as you are trying to do it as IntelliJ will want to create new module directories rather than use your existing code.
Since this question (and its accepted answer) are older and new
versions of both IDEA and PyCharm are available, I figured it would be
appropriate to add a new answer without modifying the existing
“correct” one…
My company has licenses for both PyCharm 1.5 and IntelliJ IDEA 10.5 and I have used both for regular Python development and Django web app development. From my experience, I have not found any features of PyCharm which were not available to me using the Python plugin for IntelliJ.
This makes sense if you consider the fact thet the Python IntelliJ plugin is actually maintained by the PyCharm developers at JetBrains. The only catch to this is that there could be brand new features released to a new version of PyCharm which would not be immediately available to the plugin users but it probably wouldn’t take them long to port them over.
If you are considering buying a license for IntelliJ, I would recommend to not also buy a PyCharm license as it seems like a waste of money. However, if you only do Python related development, I would recommend to only buy the PyCharm IDE instead because its licenses are cheaper than IDEA’s.
UPDATE (2013-01-23)
I have been recently using IntelliJ IDEA v12 with the latest (2.10.0) python plugin instead of PyCharm. As an experienced IDEA user, this is my preferred situation. For someone with no (or less) IDEA experience, JetBrains actually recommends starting with PyCharm because it’s UI is simpler and more focused on productivity within Python projects.
As for feature difference, JetBrains claims that the Python plugin is built from exactly the same source as PyCharm so the features should be identical. The only differences should be with the user experience, where IDEA’s plugin is slightly harder to use because that IDE isn’t aimed at Python development in the first place.
JetBrains has a FAQ that has more info about differences between the IDEA plugin and PyCharm.
IntelliJ’s comarison of IntelliJ IDEA and PyCharm.
http://confluence.jetbrains.net/display/PYH/PyCharm+vs.+IntelliJ+IDEA+Python+plugin+FAQ
From their blog:
Nov., 22nd 2012 – Just a quick heads up: we’ve just released a version
of the Python plugin for the latest Early Access Preview build of
IntelliJ IDEA 12 (build 123.4). The plugin includes the entire
functionality of the current PyCharm 2.7 EAP, including several
features which were previously only available in PyCharm (creating
virtualenvs, using remote interpreters, creating UML diagrams for
Python code etc.).
Source: http://blog.jetbrains.com/pycharm/2012/11/python-plugin-for-intellij-idea-12-is-now-available/