What is the correct syntax for Walrus operator with ternary operator?

Question

Looking at Python-Dev and StackOverflow, Python’s ternary operator equivalent is:

a if condition else b

Looking at PEP-572 and StackOverflow, I understand what Walrus operator is:

:=

Now I’m trying to to combine the "walrus operator’s assignment" and "ternary operator’s conditional check" into a single statement, something like:

other_func(a) if (a := some_func(some_input)) else b

For example, please consider the below snippet:

do_something(list_of_roles) if list_of_roles := get_role_list(username) else "Role list is [] empty"

I’m failing to wrap my mind around the syntax. Having tried various combinations, every time the interpreter throws SyntaxError: invalid syntax. My python version is 3.8.3.

My question is What is the correct syntax to embed walrus operator within ternary operator?

Asked By: BhaveshDiwan

||

Source

Answer 1

Syntactically, you are just missing a pair of parenthesis.

do_something(list_of_roles) if (list_of_roles := get_role_list(username)) else "Role list is [] empty"

If you look at the grammar, := is defined as part of a high-level namedexpr_test construct:

namedexpr_test: test [':=' test]

while a conditional expression is a kind of test:

test: or_test ['if' or_test 'else' test] | lambdef

This means that := cannot be used in a conditional expression unless it occurs inside a nested expression.

Answered By: chepner

Answer 2

For someone looking for a short answer or failing to grasp the accepted answer quickly like I did:

>>> variable = foo if (foo := 'parentheses!!') else 'otherwise'
>>> #                 ▲                      ▲
>>> #                 ╰──────────────────────╯
>>> variable
parentheses!!

Answered By: Lars Blumberg

What is the correct syntax for Walrus operator with ternary operator?

Question:

Answers: